Shooting

Suspected Sorrento murderer in custody

SORRENTO, Fla.—The man accused of killing a man in Sorrento Thursday, is in custody according to the Lake County Sheriff’s Office.

“… Justin Fout has been located and taken into custody by law enforcement. As the situation is still under investigation, additional details are not yet available,” LCSO Cpl. Chanel Martin said late Friday afternoon. 

Deputies were also attempting to locate Patricia Neeley, as person of interest in the murder of Justin Kates, 37. LCSO has not released any new information on her whereabouts.

Fout is suspected of murdering Kates during an altercation Thursday at 31504 Colby Place in Sorrento. An argument apparently escalated and Fout shot Kates, killing him. Kates was found lying in the roadway when deputies arrived on scene.

Fout fled the scene, along with Neeley, in an older model white Dodge Ram van Thursday; he was located at at undisclosed location Friday following a media release.

Previous story: https://insidelake.com/2025/02/21/deputies-searching-for-sorrento-murder-suspect/ 

 

 

Suspected Sorrento murderer in custody Read More »

Deputies searching for Sorrento murder suspect

SORRENTO, Fla.—A man is on the run, accused of killing a man in Sorrento Thursday, according to the Lake County Sheriff’s Office.

Witnesses said Justin Kates, 37, and Justin Joseph Raymond Fout, 31, engaged in a verbal argument Thursday at 31504 Colby Place in Sorrento. The argument apparently escalated and Fout shot Kates, killing him, LCSO said. He was found dead lying in the roadway when deputies arrived on scene.

Fout fled the scene, along with Patricia Neeley, in an older model white Dodge Ram van. The van should have front and rear end damage and red transfer paint on the rear; the rear right door is spray-painted black, and the left rear door window is busted out, according to LCSO.

A warrant has been issued for Fout’s arrest for second-degree murder; Neeley is not facing charges at this time, but she is a person of interest. If you have information on their whereabouts, call LCSO at 352-343-2101.

Deputies searching for Sorrento murder suspect Read More »

Victim shot and robbed Sunday, Leesburg police searching for accused gunman

LEESBURG, Fla.—Leesburg Police Department is searching for a man it says robbed and shot someone Sunday night.

Around 8 p.m., LPD responded to the 100 block of Truitt Street on a report of a shooting and found the 51-year-old victim suffering from a gunshot wound to the upper body, LPD Lt. Shannon Walsh said. Police have not released the victim’s name or gender.

The suspect fled the scene and police searched the area; Eagle One, the Lake County Sheriff’s Office helicopter, assisted in the search, but law enforcement was unable to locate him.

The victim was transported to an area hospital and is in stable condition, Walsh said. LPD detectives have identified the suspect as Henry Demetria Darity, 36, and he’s wanted for attempted homicide, armed robbery and armed trespassing.

Darity was arrested Jan. 6 for possession of methamphetamine and possession of drug paraphernalia; he was released from the Lake County Jail Jan. 30.

If you have information on Darity’s whereabouts, call LPD at 352-787-2121 or Crimeline at 1-800-423-8477; Crimeline line callers may be eligible for a reward.

Victim shot and robbed Sunday, Leesburg police searching for accused gunman Read More »

Argument about infidelity leads to shooting in Altoona

ALTOONA, Fla.—An argument about infidelity left one man shot and sent another to jail Thursday afternoon, according to the Lake County Sheriff’s Office.

Shortly before 4:15 p.m. Thursday, LCSO responded to 19331 East Altoona Road on a report of a verbal altercation, and when a deputy arrived, he found James Andrew Carroll 48, lying on his side suffering from a gunshot wound to his lower torso. The deputy rendered aid to Carroll until EMS arrived and Carroll was airlifted to HCA Florida Ocala Hospital. His condition is currently unknown, LCSO Lt. John Herrell told Inside Lake.

Carroll’s girlfriend, Shana Cottle, told LCSO Carroll was working on her vehicle when she pulled up to the home with John Cornelius Devereaux in a white Toyota Camry. Carroll began yelling vulgarities at Cottle and Devereaux, believing Cottle was being unfaithful and demanding she get out of the car, according to an affidavit.

Devereaux, 61, pulled out a silver revolver and Cottle got out the car and ran. She then heard Carroll yelling he had been shot and as she returned to the area, Carroll told Devereaux to leave. Cottle yelled at Devereaux to give her back her bag and leave. Devereaux gave her the bag and left, and she went to Carroll to check on him, according to the affidavit.

Deputies located Devereaux, who is homeless, about a mile away at a Circle K gas station and took him into custody. Deputies located the revolver and extra ammunition in the Camry and Devereaux had more than $3,000 cash in the vehicle. He told deputies the money was from his deceased mother, the arresting deputy noted in the affidavit.

Devereaux was arrested for attempted murder and is now facing an added charge of failure to provide DNA. He is being held in the Lake County Jail on no bond.

Argument about infidelity leads to shooting in Altoona Read More »

Shot fired at LCSO sergeant in Tavares, suspect identified and arrested

TAVARES, Fla.—A man who allegedly fired a shot at a Lake County Sheriff’s Office sergeant’s patrol vehicle early Thursday morning and fled the scene has been identified and arrested.

Shortly before 2:15 a.m. Thursday, the LCSO sergeant was patrolling the area of Wells Avenue in Tavares when he was flagged down by a citizen who told him a black male on a bike was rummaging through vehicles in the area. The sergeant canvassed the area and found two males and a female in front of the Peninsular Masonic Lodge, 1234 Wells Avenue. One of the men was on a e-bike, according to a probable cause affidavit.

The man on the e-bike, later identified as Norman Dywan Gunn, 35, took off in a southern direction behind the Dora Canal shopping plaza and the sergeant activated his blue lights and attempted a traffic stop. Gunn took evasive actions, partially crossing State Road 19/Duncan Drive, returned back to the plaza then headed further south into the rear of Prime Time Food Store, 1248 Wells Avenue. The business has been closed for several years. The sergeant yelled at Gunn to “stop” through his open window and Gunn reportedly yelled something like “I’m scared,” and continued to flee.

The sergeant was unable to follow path of the e-bike and believing Gunn went to the front of the store, he approached the corner of the store, and a shot was fired at his marked patrol vehicle, the affidavit states. The sergeant took a tactical position and held the scene while backup arrived.

The DYU C3 e-bike was found abandoned and LCSO CSI collected it for evidence. Deputies and LCSO’s Eagle One searched for Gunn and were assisted by Tavares Police Department but they were unable to find him. Gunn lives just .2 miles from the store where the shooting occurred.

The entire incident was recorded by the sergeant’s dash cam and the gunshot is “clearly audible, but not visually observed,” according to an LCSO detective investigating the case.

Detectives canvassed the area and a video from Circle K, 439 South Duncan Drive, showed a black male on the same e-bike arriving at the store at 1:18 a.m. The man was wearing a Checkers uniform shirt and purchased a cigar from the store. The detective recognized the man as Gunn, who works at Checkers, 480 East Burleigh Boulevard, Tavares. A witness, the same man with Gunn when the sergeant first arrived, told LCSO the man was possibly “Lion,” and gave detectives the exact location of Gunn’s home.

A warrant was issued for Gunn’s arrest for aggravated assault with a firearm, possession of a firearm by a convicted felon, and fleeing and eluding. He was arrested Thursday afternoon and transported to the Lake County Jail, where he is being held on no bond. Gunn’s neighbor, who wished to remain anonymous, told Inside Lake he was arrested and taken into custody at Checkers, and deputies searched his home on Maplewood Street early Thursday evening.

This incident comes just 3.5 months after LCSO deputies were ambushed in unincorporated Eustis Aug. 2. Master Deputy Bradley Link was killed and Master Deputy Harold Howell and Deputy Stefano Gargano both suffered gunshot wounds and are still recovering. Julie Sulpizio has been charged with multiple crimes in that case and is facing the death penalty.

Shot fired at LCSO sergeant in Tavares, suspect identified and arrested Read More »

Police on the hunt for Eustis triple shooting suspect

EUSTIS, Fla.—A warrant has been issued for the arrest of the man who police say shot three people Friday night.

Gary “Pookie” Davis, 46, is wanted for attempted murder, three counts of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and discharging a firearm in public, EPD Chief Craig Capri said.

EPD responded to a report of a shooting in front of 604 Kensington Street around 10 p.m. and found three people shot. Delmetrius Brown, 41, was shot multiple times and airlifted to Orlando Regional Medical Center; he underwent surgery and is expected to survive. Rashida Henderson, 47, was shot in the upper right leg and transported to AdventHealth Waterman in Tavares for treatment, Nyjah Lowe, 26, was struck by fragmentation and received minor injuries, Capri said.

Gary “Pookie” Davis is seen here in a 2021 mugshot. PHOTO: Lake County Sheriff’s Office

EPD detectives responded to the scene and developed information that Davis was the culprit and quickly got a warrant for his arrest, according to Capri. Capri said Davis is not in custody and police are asking anyone with information of Davis’ whereabouts to contact them.

In 2021, Davis was arrested for another shooting at the same house on Kensington Street. In that incident, Davis was accused of shooting Jarvis Griffin in an altercation involving a puppy. At the time, EPD said Davis and Griffin had been in a monthlong dispute. Davis was arrested in that case and was found not guilty by a Lake County jury in August 2023.

If you have information of Friday’s shooting, or Davis’ whereabouts, call EPD at 352-357-4121 or Crimeline at 1-800-423-TIPS.

Previous stories: BREAKING NEWS: 2 shot in Eustis Friday night – Inside Lake

Eustis Shooter Released On $12,000 Bond — Airlifted Victim Has One Bullet Removed, Second Remains – Inside Lake

Police on the hunt for Eustis triple shooting suspect Read More »

BREAKING NEWS: 2 shot in Eustis Friday night

EUSTIS, Fla.—Eustis Police Department is investigating after two people were shot Friday night.

EPD responded to the area of Kensington Street around 10 p.m. and found a male and a female suffering from gunshot wounds, EPD Chief Craig Capri told Inside Lake.

Capri said the scene was “active and fluid” and little information was available late Friday night. The victim’s names and the extent of their injuries have not been released, but at least one person was airlifted for treatment, he said.

Units were still on scene around 11:30 p.m., “They are canvassing the area for evidence,” Capri said.

No arrests had been made at press time and police did not release any information on a suspect.

This is a developing story.

 

BREAKING NEWS: 2 shot in Eustis Friday night Read More »

Leesburg shooting victim, 87, dies, 2 arrested for murder

LEESBURG, Fla.—The 87-year-old victim of a shooting in late September has died and two Leesburg men have been arrested for his murder, according to Leesburg Police Department.

Clarence Ervin, 87, of Leesburg was shot shortly before 2:45 p.m. Sept. 28, at 2101 West Main Street, as he sat in a car at a gas pump, video released by LPD showed. Ervin was transported to an area hospital and later died from his injuries on Oct. 6, LPD Lt. Shannon Walsh said.

On Friday, Kenneth D. Bailey, 22, and Craig A. Stevenson Jr., 22, were arrested on charges of capital murder and aggravated battery on a person over 65, Walsh said. They were booked into the Lake County Jail and are being held on no bond.

The third person involved in the murder has been identified, Walsh said, and detectives are working with the State Attorney’s Office to obtain an arrest warrant.

Previous story: Leesburg police release videos of suspects in shooting of man, 87 – Inside Lake

Leesburg shooting victim, 87, dies, 2 arrested for murder Read More »

Eustis police investigating after multiple shots fired Saturday afternoon

EUSTIS, Fla.—Eustis Police Department is investigating after multiple shots were fired just after noon Saturday while dozens of youth cheerleaders and football players enjoyed their Saturday game day just a few blocks away.

EPD received multiple calls about shots fired beginning at 12:01 p.m. Saturday and callers believed the shots were at Carver Park and officers rushed to the scene. Upon arrival, they found the shots actually occurred on Wall Street between Virginia Avenue and Hollywood Avenue after finding multiple shell casings and speaking with witnesses, Chief Craig Capri told Inside Lake. Carver Park is on Bates Avenue, and a gate to the back of the park is on Virginia Avenue. No one was injured in the shooting, but a bullet did go through a fence and the back window of a home on Virginia Avenue.

Detectives and EPD’s crime scene investigator responded to the scene and investigated for more than three hours, Capri said. No suspect information was released, and Capri expressed his disgust that anyone would fire shots so close to where children were gathered, referring to the suspects as “idiots.”

“We have zero tolerance for gun violence in our city,” Capri said.

PHOTO: Marilyn M. Aciego/Inside Lake

The shots startled coaches, parents and kids at the Eustis Jr. Panthers field at Carver Park. A coach from a Lakeland team retrieved a firearm from his vehicle to protect his family, he told police, and the sight of the firearm caused an altercation at the park. Officers then responded back to the park and detained the coach. He was questioned and released. Inside Lake is not naming the man because he was not charged with a crime. For safety reasons, EPD canceled the remainder of the games for the day, Capri said.

If you have information on Saturday’s shooting, call EPD at 352-357-4121 or Crimeline at 1-800-423-TIPS. Crimeline callers can remain anonymous and may be eligible for a reward.

Eustis police investigating after multiple shots fired Saturday afternoon Read More »

State to seek death penalty in August ambush attack on deputies

TAVARES, Fla.—The woman accused of helping mastermind an ambush attack on Lake County Sheriff’s Office deputies may pay for her crimes with her life.

Fifth Judicial Circuit Assistant State Attorney Kenneth Nunnelley filed a notice of intent to seek the death penalty late Tuesday afternoon in the case against Julie Sulpizio.

Sulpizio, 48, is accused of starting an altercation with her neighbors on Brookside Drive in unincorporated Eustis on Aug. 2. LCSO responded to the altercation and during a well-being check at her home, just down the street from the original call, Master Deputy Bradley Link was shot and suffered fatal wounds. In an immediate rescue attempt of Link, K9 Master Deputy Harold Howell was shot in the wrist and in a subsequent rescue attempt, Deputy Stefano Gargano was shot multiple times. Howell and Gargano have since been released from the hospital and continue to recover from their injuries.

Evidence at the scene revealed Julie’s husband, Michael, and daughters, Cheyenne and Savannah, opened fire on the deputies and all three were found dead from self-inflicted gunshot wounds after LCSO’s SWAT made entry to the home.

Sulpizio is facing a multitude of charges, including principal to first degree murder of a law enforcement officer, conspiracy to commit first degree murder, three counts of principal to attempted first degree murder of a law enforcement officer, three counts of battery and one count of battery on a law enforcement officer.

Sulpizio is being held on no bond at an undisclosed detention center and has pleaded not guilty.

State to seek death penalty in August ambush attack on deputies Read More »

Scroll to Top